Feb 21, 2008

defying logic

“The important question for John McCain today is, is he going to learn the right lesson from this, and what is the lesson?” Mr. Limbaugh said, according to a transcript posted on his Web site. “The lesson is liberals are to be defeated. You cannot walk across the aisle with them. You cannot reach across the aisle. You cannot welcome their media members on your bus and get all cozy with them and expect eternal love from them.”

the above from an article in the Times, covering McCain's response response to their own report on his relationship with a lobbyist 8 years ago.

while a focus on limbaugh is not the point of the article, they included his quote at the end to show how staunch conservatives have reacted.

the us/them mentality of limbaugh et al really baffles me sometimes. i guess that sort of rhetoric is large part of what attracts his listeners.

maybe i'm being dramatic, but i feel like this sort of discussion IS NEVER beneficial. even in limbaugh's book, aren't liberals still americans, as in not enemies?

2 comments:

Cullin Spellings said...

ahh my friend, you come to a great question.

conservatism vs liberalism

is ti good vs evil... no

but it is a real competition and one side is the opposition.

rush says enemy, he uses that to drive home the seriousness of the point

i know we disagree on how to go about our political goals, but this is simply a explanation of limbaughs words.

stan said...

unfortunately for him, whenever i read an argument like that, his tone distracts me from his words. by equating a rival political faction with "the enemy", (which i'm sure he would also call terrorists) he places my focus on his belligerent phrases. even if he wanted to make a good argument--which he is not--it would be lost. if he were to rest on the merits of his own argument rather than on the laurels of his loud, bombastic personality, i might be persuaded. or at least more willing to listen.

he doesn't and i'm not.